Santa and the Goodnight Train

September 1, 2019
Not quite the Polar Express.... Sobel's rhyming text fails to deliver a clear premise for the eponymous goodnight train's Christmas Eve progress through the pages, and Huliska-Beith's acrylic paintings embellished with fabric and paper collage don't clarify the storytelling. At the start of the picture book, a bevy of anthropomorphic animals decorates a rather rickety-looking engine, and then human children gather around and pile into train cars that look like beds and cribs. The train follows a track, seemingly in pursuit of Santa's sleigh, but to what end isn't clear. They travel "through a town of gingerbread" and through the woods to find the sleigh blocking the tracks and the reindeer snoozing while, mystifyingly, Santa counts some sheep. Perching the sleigh on the train's cowcatcher, they all proceed to the North Pole, where the "elves all cheer. / Santa's here until next year!" But then the goodnight train just...leaves, "heading home on Christmas Eve." Was this a dream? It definitely wasn't a story with a satisfying beginning, middle, and end. Santa's face is never seen; the human children and elves are diverse. A Christmas train book that gets derailed by a lacking story arc. (Picture book. 2-4)

COPYRIGHT(2019) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.